Gujarat Appeals In Bilkis Bano Case, Wants “Adverse Comments” Dropped

A month after the Supreme Court ordered that the 11 men convicted of raping Bilkis Bano and killing her family during the 2002 riots must return to jail, the Gujarat government has approached the court and sought the removal of some “adverse” comments made against it in the judgment. 

In its order on January 8, the Supreme Court bench of Justices BV Nagarathna and Ujjal Bhuyan had observed that “State of Gujarat has acted on the basis of the direction issued by this Court but contrary to the letter and spirit of law” and  “acted in tandem and was complicit with” one of the convicts in the case who had played a fraud on the court and misrepresented or suppressed material facts.

In the May 2022 order, based on a petition by convict Radheshyam Shah, the Supreme Court had directed the Gujarat government to consider his remission application under its remission policy.  Complying with that order, the court had remarked in January, “could also be said to be an instance of usurpation of power and abuse of discretion”.

Pointing out that it had followed an order of the Supreme Court itself, the Gujarat government has said in its review petition that it was “bound to comply” since it was a party to the case.